Over the last few years, I've developed a passion for hiking, and more recently, running up mountains. It's been a lot of fun going around and summitting various peaks in the Northeast. Unfortunately, I have yet to have any mountain adventures outside of this region, but there's also a lot to see here. I hope to expand on my current list of summits and explore other areas of the US, but for now I still have a decent list of summits. Not all mountains are made equal, and that is quite clear when comparing small viewless mountains in southern New England with alpine ones further north. I enjoy rankings like this, and with many new mountains added this year, it seems appropriate to do this as I have no future mountain plans until next summer, and while I could add a few to the list, it's fair to say my mountain running "season" is over. To rank the mountains, I came up with 4 categories that represent how great a mountain can be: the views, the summit, the trails, and the elevation. I rated the first three categories out of 10, and the elevation was mostly used to distinguish bigger mountains from smaller ones. For example, some of the Acadia NP mountains would get high marks in all three categories but it wouldn't feel right to rank them ahead of any white mountains, as the whites are much higher. I assigned the following elevation ratings: 8000+ feet=5, 5,000+ feet=4, 3,000+ feet= 3, 1,500+ feet= 2, 0-1499 feet= 1. A perfect score would be a 35, scoring 10s in every category and being above 8,000 feet.
Note that with all my rankings, this is completely subjective and based off my experiences there. I unfortunately had to exclude the following mountains as it was very foggy the days I summitted them and I am unable to provide a view rating: Moosilaukee, Jackson, Willey, Webster, Cannon, Bare (MA), Greylock, Holyoke, Hitchcock. Here are the rankings for the 60 mountains I've done, specifically the bottom 20 so the post isn't extremely long. I'll try to remember to update this if I end up adding a few in the next months. I tried to put photos where I could. All photos were taken by me except otherwise noted but I didn't add any photos taken by someone who wasn't with me.
60. Round Mountain (CT)
Elevation: 2,297'
# of Summits: 2 (July 2018, July 2020)
View Rating: 3
Summit Rating: 2
Trail Rating: 3
Elevation Rating: 2
Overall Rating: 10
 |
| (Stolen from the Gazelle Running Blog) |
Coming in last is Round Mountain in Salisbury, CT just south of the Massachusetts border. It really feels like a subpeak of Mt. Frissell and likely does not much prominence. While Round Mountain isn't a bad mountain, there's just nothing remarkable about it and it isn't one I'd recommend. There's only trail going towards it which has been horribly overgrown both times I've done it, the views are mostly obscured by small trees and the summit itself is simply a pile of rocks on the side of the trails. The summit is fairly tight and definitely not a great place to stop. Nothing wrong with round mountain, just one of the least exciting mountains on the list.
59. Saddle Ball Mountain (MA)
Elevation: 3,238'
# of Summits: 1 (April 2018)
View Rating: 1
Summit Rating: 1
Trail Rating: 5
Elevation Rating: 3
Overall Rating: 10
As the second highest peak in Massachusetts, Saddle Ball mountain seems really cool but is nothing more than a high point in the middle of the woods, without even as much as a cairn to mark it. The worst summits are the ones you don't realize you summited until you start going down. There are no viewpoints anywhere along the way. However, the trail that goes over Saddle Ball and towards Greylock is still a cool ridgeline trail (just below treeline) through pine forest which gives it the edge over Round Mountain.
58. Mount Megunticook (ME)
Elevation: 1,385'
# of Summits: 1 (July 2018)
View Rating: 1
Summit Rating: 1
Trail Rating: 8
Elevation Rating: 1
Overall Rating: 11
It's a shame to rank mount megunticook so low, because Camden Hills is a really nice area and has other great summits and views in the park. The trails around Megunticook are a lot of fun, technical and steep but minimal scrambling (quite runnable). While nearby Ocean Lookout is technically on the slope of the mountain and is a great view, the summit itself is nothing more than a cairn in the woods (there may be a sign as well). Since Ocean lookout is not directly on the way to the summit and there are many routes to the summit that could be viewless, it's not the most exciting mountain even if there are nice views nearby and great trails.
57. Mount Frissell (MA)
Elevation: 2,454'
# of Summits: 2 (July 2018, July 2020)
View Rating: 5
Summit Rating: 1
Trail Rating: 4
Elevation Rating: 2
Overall Rating: 12
Coming slightly ahead of Round Mountain, Frissell is very similar (Round is basically a subpeak on the slope of Frissell). It's still fairly unexciting as the summit is completely wooded/viewless but it gets a few points over Round as there are some cool steep rock slabs going up to it and there's a few decent lookouts just near the summit.
56. West Peak (CT)
Elevation: 1,024'
# of Summits: 2 (June 2018, December 2019)
View Rating: 3
Summit Rating: 3
Trail Rating: 6
Elevation Rating: 1
Overall Rating: 13
There's nothing wrong with West Peak, in fact, it's a rather nice hilly running spot (Hubbard Park) in Central Connecticut. There's a solid viewpoint at the summit, although not panoramic and the area is too urban for the views to be too special.
55. Mount Tom (NH)
Elevation: 4,052'
# of Summits: 1 (June 2020)
View Rating: 2
Summit Rating: 3
Trail Rating: 6
Elevation Rating: 3
Overall Rating: 14
While Mount Tom is a 4,000 footer, it's quite lacking in views or epic trail sections as the trail (an OAB to the summit), including the summit is completely wooded. There's at least a cairn marking it and it doesn't feel as tight as some other wooded summits on this list, but it's disappointing there's no clear overlook anywhere to get great views. You can kind of peek through the trees and barely see the landscape in the distance but there's no special views to stop for.
54. East Peak (CT)
Elevation: 976'
# of Summits: 2 (June 2018, December 2019)
View Rating: 3
Summit Rating: 5
Trail Rating: 6
Elevation Rating: 1
Overall Rating: 15
 |
(Stolen from the gazelle running blog)
|
As the second peak of the Hanging Hills, East Peak is very similar and close to West Peak. However, the summit is better as it's more open, giving a greater degree of views to take in, and castle craig, a stone building with stairs to the top adds a bit to it.
53. Mount Norwottuck (MA)
Elevation: 1,106'
# of Summits: 2 (April 2017, May 2020)
View Rating: 5
Summit Rating: 3
Trail Rating: 6
Elevation Rating: 1
Overall Rating: 15
 |
(Stolen from the Gazelle Running Blog)
|
The Holyoke range in Western Massachusetts doesn't rival the Berkshires in height, but are quite cool and interesting on their own right. However, each mountain in particular is pretty small and unremarkable. The ridgeline is great, and Norwottuck is the highest point of that. It offers a small summit with decent views towards Amherst, although it's not a very wide viewpoint. Trails are fun and steep but nothing special and feels very similar to many CT blue blazed trails.
52. Ragged Mountain (CT)
Elevation: 761'
# of Summits: 2 (July 2017, August 2020)
View Rating: 5
Summit Rating: 5
Trail Rating: 6
Elevation Rating: 1
Overall Rating: 17
Despite being the smallest non-coastal mountain on the list, Ragged has some surprisingly nice lookouts and trails. There's some nice reservoirs on the west side of the mountain that make the views nicer. The trails are very technical and hard to run on, not my favorite (beds of jagged rock) but certainly unique. It's definitely a cool spot but the mountain just isn't big enough to rank higher.
51. Mount Tom (MA)
Elevation: 1,201'
# of Summits: 1 (May 2018)
View Rating: 6
Summit Rating: 2
Trail Rating: 8
Elevation Rating: 1
Overall Rating: 17
As a state reservation, Mount Tom is awesome, with a great mix of wooded trail, some technical and hilly, but still some flat trails around a pond. The highlight is easily the portion of the Metacomet-Monadnock trail, a 180 degree open technical trail along cliffs that goes for a mile which is probably one of the best stretches of trail in Massachusetts. There's decent valley views at the summit and along the ledges, nothing special due to the lack of height/amazing surrounding environment but similar to CT and other MA mtn views. Unfortunately as much as I like this place, the summit is very disappointing. There's radio towers all over, graffiti, cement, fences, and metal railings in poor condition. It's quite unpleasant to look at and really takes away from the natural beauty of the place.
50. Prospect Mountain (NY)
Elevation: 2,030'
# of Summits: 1 (September 2017)
View Rating: 7
Summit Rating: 5
Trails Rating: 3
Elevation Rating: 2
Overall Rating: 17
 |
(Stolen from the gazelle running blog)
|
Prospect Mountain gets points over the last two as the views are more impressive, mostly from the extra elevation and more mountainous area at the south edge of the Adirondacks. Lake George downtown and the lake itself offer some variety in the views as well. However the trails are quite lacking, with a dearth of options and certain trails being poorly established/marked. There's an auto road to the summit which takes a little away from the summit itself.
49. Mount Rowe (NH)
Elevation: 1,680'
# of Summits: 1 (July 2020)
View Rating: 6
Summit Rating: 3
Trails Rating: 6
Elevation Rating: 2
Overall Rating: 17
Mount Rowe is essentially a side peak of Gunstock Mountain. The summit is fairly lame as it's wooded and marked by a radio tower, but there's a decent semi-open nearby ledge view. The biggest draw is probably the trails as the entire Belknap has a very well marked/established trail system with many option for each summit and a single trail traversing most of the range.
48. Belknap Mountain (NH)
Elevation: 2,382'
# of Summits: 1 (July 2020)
View Rating: 5
Summit Rating: 3
Trails Rating: 7
Elevation Rating: 2
Overall Rating: 17
A few peaks over from Rowe, Belknap is the highest peak in the Belknap range and highest point in Belknap county. Like Rowe, the summit is wooded, although Belknap has a fire tower which offers okay, if somewhat obscured views (the views off the south slope are much better). The trails are slightly better than Rowe as Rowe has a service road for its portion of the Belknap Range trail and there's some cool open rock running.
47. Loon Mountain (NH)
Elevation: 3,065'
# of Summits: 3 (July 2016, July 2017, July 2018)
View Rating: 8
Summit Rating: 5
Trails Rating: 3
Elevation Rating: 3
Overall Rating: 19
 |
(Photo from my mom)
|
While Loon offers great views of the some of the higher mountain peaks for miles, it can't escape the mediocre category due to the lack of real trails. The ski area summit doesn't really do it any favors either. It's easy to enjoy the views but generally isn't a great running or hiking spot, the biggest reason why the race there isn't especially fun/unique.
46. Mount Sunapee (NH)
Elevation: 2,726'
# of Summits: 1 (August 2020)
View Rating: 7
Summit Rating: 4
Trails Rating: 6
Elevation Rating: 2
Overall Rating: 19
Sunapee, as ski resort, is pretty similar to Loon. The resort is smaller, the summit is smaller and the views are slightly worse. However, Sunapee gets the edge, as being a State Park, there are several singletrack trails on both slopes of the mountain which is a lot more fun than running up service roads.
45. Brace Mountain (NY)
Elevation: 2,310'
# of Summits: 1 (July 2020)
View Rating: 7
Summit Rating: 6
Trails Rating: 4
Elevation Rating: 2
Overall Rating: 19
For a smaller mountain, Brace has pretty nice valley views and a partially open grassy summit, both significantly better than the ones on nearby Mount Frissell and Round Mountain. However, the trails are mediocre in at least 2 of the 3 directions (I haven't gone south from there). Going towards on the S. Taconic trail is a fairly lame doubletrack and poorly marked trail and going east towards CT is an extremely overgrown trail many times of the year. Solid peak, but nothing more.
44. Long Mountain (MA)
Elevation: 920'
# of Summits: 1 (May 2020)
View Rating: 7
Summit Rating: 3
Trails Rating: 8
Elevation Rating: 1
Overall Rating: 19
Long Mountain is the easternmost peak of the Holyoke range, and despite being smaller than Norwottuck, the viewpoints around it are somewhat better and certainly much more open. The summit is wooded and unclear where it exactly is, so far from dramatic. The stretch of trail is a little more fun and exciting than the one over Norwottuck as well.
43. Bear Mountain (NY)
Elevation: 1,283'
# of Summits: 1 (May 2019)
View Rating: 6
Summit Rating: 6
Trails Rating: 6
Elevation Rating: 1
Overall Rating: 19
Bear Mountain in the Hudson Highlands is solid in every category. Decent views, large summit, and quality trails. However, it's not great in a single category. The views are partially obscured by bush growth in every direction. Many of the trail are manicured doubletrack, including part of the Appalachian trail. The summit is full of tourists who took the autoroad up. It's an enjoyable and easy mountain to summit, but is lacking in certain areas.
42. Wachusett Mountain (MA)
Elevation: 2,005'
# of Summits: 1 (June 2020)
View Rating: 4
Summit Rating: 4
Trails Rating: 9
Elevation Rating: 2
Overall Rating: 19
 |
(Stolen from the Gazelle running blog)
|
With a grassy, open summit with radio towers, and not a lot of views due to growing vegetation, summiting Wachusett isn't the most special experience. What brings it up greatly is a large and generally fantastic trail system. There are many miles of diverse singletrack, from flat dirt on the base to very technical rock hopping and scrambling towards the top. The amount of trail and the technical factor is uncommon for the area and height of the mountain, which makes it all the more impressive. It's no surprise many Massachusetts mountain runners opt to run here often when they can't drive further up.
41. Mount Pierce (NH)
Elevation: 4,311'
# of Summits: 2 (June 2018, August 2020)
View Rating: 7
Summit Rating: 3
Trails Rating: 7
Elevation Rating: 3
Overall Rating: 20

To honest, Pierce probably doesn't deserve to be this low. It's a 4000 footer and has some pretty good views nearby. It's just hard not to compare to the rest of the Presidentials, which are easily some of the best mountains in the Northeast, and Pierce is significantly worse in every way compared to them. There are decent views just past the summit, but unlike the other Presidentials, there is very little above treeline trail around Pierce. Due to this, there isn't really any of the breathtaking vistas found in the other presidential peaks. The summit is wooded although the woods aren't quite as dense as some other peaks so there are still sort of views. The trail to Eisenhower is awesome, fairly gradual while the trails descending towards Crawford notch are standard, steep and technical White mountain slopes. Pierce is a nice mountain, it just doesn't compare with its neighbors.
I'll stop here to make these posts manageable to make in the future. None of these are bad mountains, they're just generally not fantastic either. The next tier will focus on the middle 20 which are all pretty solid.